Saturday, May 24, 2014

"This is not intended as an argument against abortion..."

From Theo Malekin:

When I was six, my friend Tom died. My Mum took me aside when I got home from school and explained that he had gone into the hospital for routine surgery but something had gone wrong. She said it was just as well that he had died. You see, Tom had Down syndrome. 
I don't mean to slander my mother. Like my father, she thought this was humane and rational -- that we should not cling to life if that life is one of terrible suffering. She was repeating the conventional wisdom of the day, and that wisdom said that if you had Down syndrome, your life was not worth living. Others who ought to have known better were often worse. In the eyes of many doctors, children with Down syndrome were burdens that would bring only disappointment to their families and they pressed parents to put their children in institutions and tell everyone that the baby had died. These children, it was believed, would never be any use to anyone, and their birth was treated as a tragedy. 
This is not intended as an argument against abortion. It is an argument for giving prospective parents of children with Down syndrome a full picture of what their life will be like. 
My daughter Hazel was born with Down syndrome five years ago. I found myself thinking of Tom a lot in the months that followed her birth. My wife and I, and especially Hazel, are lucky that things have changed since Tom died. Hazel has had an array of specialists who have helped her learn to walk and talk and she goes to a regular elementary school with other 'normal' kids. She still has challenges. We haven't got her potty-trained yet. On the other hand, she knows her alphabet and she can count better than some of her classmates. She likes learning and she is enthusiastic about going to school. Much more than I ever was. I hated school. 
We were also lucky that the head of the pediatric intensive care unit where Hazel spent her first month of life had a positive outlook on children with Down Syndrome. I remember him telling us not to place limits on what she could do, his relief when it became clear we were committed to our daughter. You see, old attitudes persist. Some people still believe that children with Down syndrome are a burden, their lives not worth living. A lot of people, to judge by message boards under articles about pregnancy screening. The problem is compounded by the doctors who present prospective parents with a uniformly gloomy outlook. Many parents of kids with Down syndrome can attest to this. In some cases, rather than congratulations new parents get a barrage of health statistics and there is still often an assumption by medical professionals that women carrying a child with Down syndrome will terminate the pregnancy. Around 80 percent of women who get a positive test for Down syndrome still choose to have an abortion. Yet I cannot think of any parents of a child with Down syndrome who would give them up for anything. 
Love has a way of making statistics irrelevant, and it brings its own kind of knowing. I do not love my daughter any less because she has Down syndrome. Her diagnosis says very little about who she is. She is not a disease or a syndrome but an individual: affectionate, naughty, infuriating at times, stubborn, self-willed and utterly charming. Certainly she has medical problems and developmental challenges not faced by other children. I'm not saying those don't exist. But they're one part of a much bigger picture. 
This is not intended as an argument against abortion. It is an argument for giving prospective parents of children with Down syndrome a full picture of what their life will be like. It includes a lot of work. Their child will likely have more medical problems due to their condition, and it will take time and effort to reach developmental milestones that other parents take for granted. But all these challenges are manageable, especially with the level of support available now. Expecting parents need at least to talk to the family of a child with Down syndrome. Otherwise they cannot know what it is like or what to expect. Statistics cannot tell you this. 
It is also an argument for changing attitudes that appear self-evident to too much of the general population. You cannot know if someone else's life is worth living without asking them and without even knowing them. A disability does not necessarily stop you living a full, satisfying life. Oddly enough, I'm not sure that disabilities have anything to do with living full satisfying lives. When it comes to Hazel, her life is not a burden to her family but an unending source of delight. For my part, I cannot imagine life without her. But most importantly, her life is valuable to herself, and definitely worth living.

But it is an argument against abortion. It is an argument for the sanctity of life-- every life. It is an argument that human worth is not determined by a test. It is not a matter of sentience, or intelligence, or even health or suffering.

Human worth is merely a matter of being human. We all have the same worth-- transcendent worth.

Mr. Malekin's experience is the experience that I see with nearly all of the families of the handicapped kids I care for (most of my patients are handicapped kids). These kids are a joy and a grace to their families. There can be hard times, of course, but life is about hard times. None of us ever really escape them, completely.

Our eugenic abortion culture is a lie about these kids and their families. Handicapped children are a gift, as are all children, and we need to clear away our pride and our fear to see them as they, and we, really are.   

7 comments:

  1. Commissar Boggs, Ministry of TruthMay 24, 2014 at 7:35 AM

    Just so we get to hear both sides, here's the argument for abortion:

    On the subway, Peter asked, ''Shouldn't we consider having triplets?'' And I had this adverse reaction: ''This is why they say it's the woman's choice, because you think I could just carry triplets. That's easy for you to say, but I'd have to give up my life.'' Not only would I have to be on bed rest at 20 weeks, I wouldn't be able to fly after 15. I was already at eight weeks. When I found out about the triplets, I felt like: It's not the back of a pickup at 16, but now I'm going to have to move to Staten Island. I'll never leave my house because I'll have to care for these children. I'll have to start shopping only at Costco and buying big jars of mayonnaise.
    --- NYT, 2004

    Move to Staten Island? Shop at Costco??? Buy mayo in JUMBO JARS???!!!

    Kill the kids.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Commissar Boggs, Ministry of TruthMay 24, 2014 at 8:10 AM

    Progressive Insight for the Day™:

    When You're A Porn Star, Privacy Is A Luxury
    --- HuffPo

    Who knew?

    If you happen to see Sweetcheeks Bejay in a porn movie or on stage, and notice that she looks exactly like Darlene Goggleheimer from Composition II, it's a Progressocrime. It's not human recognition, it's "outing".

    But it gets worse...

    If you know a math major, you might ask them for a favor with trig.
    If you know an English major, you might ask them for a favor with an essay.
    If you know a plumber, you might ask them for a favor with a leaky toilet.

    But if you know a "sex worker", despite the fact that IT'S A PERFECTLY FINE OCCUPATIONAL CHOICE, you should never ask them for a favor with...

    Well, you get the picture (no pun intended).

    And you must never, ever recognize them. When Sweetcheeks is down to that last wisp of g-string, you must never stand up and bellow "Darlene!! Did you get your research paper turned in on time??"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What’s the matter grandpa, pissed that someone would write an article that treats sex workers like human beings instead of loathsome pieces of meat that deserve what they get?

      -KW

      Delete
    2. Commissar Boggs, Ministry of TruthMay 24, 2014 at 4:04 PM

      If they were "loathsome pieces of meat" they'd starve to death.

      Find a different whine, ignoramus.

      Delete
    3. They are human beings, KW. That is why we think it is bad for them to take up the occupation of 'sex worker'. And we point out that both the 'sex workers' and you lot agree with us that this is bad when you want to hide what they do from public view.

      Delete
  3. the urge to kill the mentally handicapped in the womb has led, like night into day, to the urge to kill mentally handicapped adults. and when you think about it, they're morally indistinguishable.

    naidoo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Naidoo, dont you know? It's all about choices today. Whatever the latest fashion is. Look....

      All the ice cream flavors

      Mmmmmm ,yum, yum........so many choices!




      Human life? Vacuum and incinerate. Government says it's OK so it must be OK!

      Delete